GUIDE | UNEARTHED

Dark Waters

(Mariano Baino, Italy/Russia/UK, 1993)

BY TOM PHELAN | November 19, 2026
SHARE:

In Dark Waters (1993), Italian filmmaker Mariano Baino solves the Lovecraft problem. I imagine a less sensitive director briefing his creative collaborators: “Make me a cosmic nightmare—I want it cheap, and it had better be as unspeakable as it is indescribable.” Rather than attempt the impossible, Baino leans the other way by creating a distinctive world meticulously crafted from stone, candle wax, saltwater, and blood. He fashions a dream object so elementally physical that you feel you could hold it in your hands, turning it over and admiring the fine detail as you fall under its spell.

Elizabeth (Louise Salter) visits a convent on a lonely island where her friend Theresa (Anna Rose Phipps) has been staying. As she and her guide Sarah (Venera Simmons), who has a taste for Sherlock Holmes, investigate the convent, they are beset by nuns. Like cops who take on the brutal traits of the criminals they rub elbows with, the nuns have turned every bit as bloodthirsty as the creature they appear to be keeping in the catacombs under lock and key. One of the pleasures of the film is trying to determine whether they are serving the demon or protecting us from it.

In a dream, Elizabeth walks through an island cave that looks like a cracked-open geode studded with burning candles rather than crystals. This is what we mean when we say “texture.” More warp and weft: nuns silhouetted against the sky in a line on a hilltop, holding crosses aloft as a bell tolls; dead fish tightly packed like an abstract mosaic on a bright beach; a woman hanging for dear life from a rope in a storm, darkness behind her and falling rain sparkling in the foreground like a brocade curtain of light; and a church drowned in an implosion of water in the film’s marvelous, wordless opening. The sustained camera push-in on an old woman embroidering the beast’s image onto a scrap of cloth suggests that Baino knows how the spells are woven.

Add to these visual delights the sonic texture of mewling infants, howling demons, crackling flames, and water burbling everywhere. This sound collage is accompanied by the rare ’90s synth score that doesn’t batter your nerves with reedy, nasal squealing. Composer Igor Clark provides a pleasantly dark liturgical atmosphere and at least one hummable melody. Even the dialogue has a soft textural quality to it, especially when Elizabeth is talking to Sarah, her fellow explorer. Salter’s voice soothes as she speculates on the secrets of the island, in a scene no doubt featured on an ASMR whisper-video playlist somewhere. Compare that to the voice of the Mother Superior, who speaks an indecipherable language that sounds as if she has made a grammar of the croaks coming from the mouth of Kayako, the ghost in Ju-on. And the growl that comes from the upturned face of the nun on the cross, as she glides toward Elizabeth in one of the scariest shots I’ve seen in any movie, is primal and unforgettable.

The original vision in the artist’s mind—ideal, vivid, and complete—rarely survives its passage into the world. It shatters as it leaves the brain, and the artist must piece together some semblance of it from the fragments, like the amulet in Dark Waters, which only summons the beast when whole. Through his extraordinary reverence for image and sound, economical use of gore, and singular devotion to a tactile dreamworld, Baino succeeds in unleashing the beast into the mind of the audience. 🩸

TOM PHELAN,

a writer living outside Philadelphia, is currently working on a horror project set in western Pennsylvania. He co-wrote the movie Anamorph, starring Willem Dafoe.

How to see Dark Waters:

RELATED CONTENT
    FRESH BLOOD
REVIEW
(Ken Russell, UK, 1971)

Ken Russell’s The Devils begins like a Ken Russell film. A glitzed-out Louis XIII (Graham Armitage) rises like Venus, campy on a clamshell in a painted sea, while Renaissance dance music plays.

BY TOM PHELAN  |  October 28, 2026

GUIDE | UNEARTHED
(Robert Sigl, West Germany/Hungary, 1989)

Like the best fairy tales, which often portray darkness through the lens of childhood innocence, Laurín tells a dreamily surreal story of hardened youth. The title character is a young girl whose mental state is not initially clear...

BY LAURA KERN  |  March 17, 2022

GUIDE | CORE HORROR
(Dario Argento, Italy, 1977)

It’s a positively daunting task to come up with anything new and insightful to say about canonical films that have been discussed, analyzed, and adored to death. Because of this, the most beloved titles...

BY LAURA KERN  |  November 6, 2026

RECOMMENDED
    RAVENOUS
GUIDE | ORIGINS

Supernatural

(Victor Halperin, USA, 1933)

This pre-Code offering packs a lot of story into its typically brisk running time, with several plot threads weaving together a (not always successful) tapestry of spooky and criminal doings.

READ MORE >

BY  ANN OLSSON  |  Month 00, 2021

REVIEW

The Keep

(Michael Mann, USA, 1983)

In what could be the fastest-resulting rape revenge movie, a drunken lout brutally forces himself on Ida, the young woman who doesn't return his affections, during a party over Labor Day.

READ MORE >

BY  LAURA KERN  |  Month 00, 2021

REVIEW

We Need To Do Something

(Sean King O'Grady, USA, 2021)

Beast is a lot of movies in one package - fractured fairy tale, belated-coming-of-age story, psychological drama, regional horror film - but above all it's a calling card for its leading lady, Jessie Buckley.

READ MORE >

BY  LAURA KERN  |  Month 00, 2021